New York, NY (September 4, 2002) - A simple, low-cost ultrasound
screening of men over 60 is not only reliably accurate in detecting
abdominal aortic aneurysms (AAA) but is cost-effective in increasing
quality-adjusted life years (QALYs). That is the finding of physicians
from the Division of Vascular Surgery of New York-Presbyterian
Hospital-Weill Cornell Medical College, in an article published
in the latest issue of the journal Surgery. The authors,
led by Dr. K. Craig Kent, Chief of the Division of Vascular Surgery
at NewYork-Presbyterian Hospital, conclude that screening for
AAA in men over 60 should be covered by insurance plans, including
Medicare. At present, no major plan provides for such coverage.
NewYork-Presbyterian's Division of Vascular Surgery has played
a leading role in developing the new "Quick Screen"
technology, which can be applied to women as well as men.
The aorta is the main artery that brings blood from the heart
into the legs. In some individuals the aorta will widen or dilate
developing a bulge called an aneurysm. When the aorta becomes
too wide, it will rupture like a balloon that is overfilled. Most
patients with ruptured aneurysms do not survive.
"The number of patients who present to hospitals with ruptured
AAA in the U.S. each year is approximately 15,000," the authors
write. Many other patients who have aneurysms die of rupture without
ever reaching medical attention. Because of the aging population,
and because possible interventions exist, "it is imperative
that programs be developed . . . to detect this fatal condition
before symptoms occur."
The investigators screened 25 patients with risk factors for AAA.
The factors were either a family history of AAA or three or more
of the following: age greater than 60 years, current or former
smoker, high blood pressure, elevated cholesterol, heart disease,
a history of leg bypass surgery, difficulty walking or symptoms
related to poor circulation in the legs, and carotid artery disease
or stroke.
All of the subjects were evaluated both through a rapid, less-than-five-minute
ultrasound, which the authors call a "Quick Screen,"
and also through a standard abdominal aortic ultrasound, which
required, on average, 24 minutes. Seven patients were found to
have aneurysms, and the Quick Screen was found to be 100% reliable
in detecting the condition, suggesting that this easy and less
costly technique can be used to screen patients for aneurysms.
To determine whether screening is cost-effective relative to other
medical interventions, the authors used what is known as a Markov
decision-analysis model. The measure used by the physicians for
evaluating cost-effectiveness is called the "cost per quality
of adjusted life year saved." In layman's terms, this is
the amount of money that society or insurers need to pay to prolong
a patient's life by one year. The "cost per quality of adjusted
life year saved" for common interventions, such as heart
surgery or mammography screening for breast cancer, are $9,500
and $16,000, respectively. The authors found that the cost-effective
ratio for screening for aneurysms was $11,000, making this test
as cost-effective as these other commonly used interventions.
These data convincingly demonstrate that this simple and noninvasive
test can be useful in saving lives. Moreover, the test is less
or equal in expense to that of most common medical interventions
that are currently available.
"Our data suggest that all males above the age of 60 should
be screened," the authors write. "Women who have a family
history of aneurysmal disease should also be screened." If,
as they hope, the recommendation is adopted by Medicare and other
insurers, the result may be a significant change in routine care
for older men and women--and many extended lives.
Besides Dr. Kent, the authors include Drs. Thomas Y. Lee, Peter
Korn, Jennifer A. Heller, Sashi Kilaru, Frederick P. Beavers,
and Harry L. Bush.

